Spread the Word ...
del.icio.us Digg Furl Reddit StumbleUpon Help
BOOKOPINION REVIEW: “God is a Verb” – Buckminster Fuller.
“Raw” is the first instinctive definition that appeals to me when I try to characterize my feelings about “The Shack” by William P. Young. And not just raw in the traditional sense…raw emotions, raw pain, etc. But ruthlessly honest, words honed to a fine point somewhere beyond what one is capable of reasoning.

This intriguing story opens with a camping trip involving Mack, his son Josh, daughter Kate and the beautiful little six year old, Missy. But when Mack momentarily turns his back on Missy to rescue his son from drowning in an overturned canoe, Missy is silently abducted and, being unfound by a massive search, finally assumed brutally murdered by a serial killer. This tragedy throws Mack into a downward spiral of what he refers to as “The Great Sadness” and his constant companion, “if only, if only.” Eventually, the family begins, in some measure, to cope with the situation and appears to move forward. Nan, Mack’s wife, whose relationship with God is her constant source of comfort, actually even refers to Him lovingly as “Papa.” But Mack is different. His relationship with God is broken and bitter and he functions merely because it is a necessity to do so. And then, suddenly, everything changes.
Mack receives a note….from Papa, instructing Mack to meet Him at the shack where Missy had been murdered. And now, reason flees from Mack. God wrote a note? Was this someone’s idea of a really horrible, sadistic joke? Since when does God write letters? And without realizing it, Mack has made a decision…he will go. He doesn’t wish to disclose to Nan what has occurred and, fortuitously, she decides to take Josh and Kate to visit her sister and extend spring break by a week.
As soon as Nan and the children have left, Mack begins making plans for the trip. He then packs up a four wheel drive Jeep and heads out for northeastern Oregon, the last place on earth he wishes to revisit. But when he arrives, he doesn’t find exactly what he expects. As he begins the climb to the cabin, winter begins to disappear. Instead of ice and snow and leaden skies, there are summer wildflowers blossoming everywhere. And the shack has now become a beautiful little log cabin, surrounded by pungent herbs and fragrant flowers. Mack now suspects he is having a psychotic break.
The front door opens and Mack is confronted by a large, African-American woman who immediately lifts him off his feet, spins him around and professes her delight in seeing him. Within seconds, Mack meets a fragile looking, Asian woman and a middle eastern man dressed like a laborer. Who are these people? They obviously expected to see Mack, they know him, seemingly quite well, but he is a bit overwhelmed and questions are gathering in his mind.
When the large black woman introduces herself as “Elousia” Mack is bewildered. Then she tells Mack to just call her what Nan does. This is “Papa?” And the laborer? He tells Mack to call Him Jesus if he likes or even Yeshua. And the Asian woman indentifies herself as Sarayu, keeper of the gardens. When Mack is finally able to ask “Which one of you is God”, all three respond in unison, “I am”.
What follows must surely be pure fantasy. Or is it? Is Mack having a complete breakdown? Or could this be true that God is responding to the pain in Mack’s heart? And how is Mack going to be healed if this is truth? What will this journey cost him? And what will be the gain?
“The Shack” is well written, evenly paced and frankly, shocking. The characters are well drawn, the humor is fantastic and the story breaks your heart. I think William P. Young stepped outside of himself when he wrote this book and wanted to see God, Jesus, the Holy Spirit, the Trinity, whatever you want to call it, in a new light. He definitely succeeded. It’s not quite like any other book I’ve ever read…at times I would think, “Aha, C.S. Lewis” and then turn the page and retract that conviction.
I think everyone who reads “The Shack” will come away with something unique for themselves alone, something very personal. If you choose to read it, please don’t skip. Every word is alive with meaning, every expression, enlightening. Do I recommend it? Absolutely!
– Elizabeth Channery
N.Y. Times Book Reviews
The New Yorker Book Reviews
Publishers Weekly Book Reviews
USA Today Book Reviews
- No need to add water or sand to enjoy these summer reads
- Book Buzz: Freeman finally takes on role as Mandela
- 'Assisted Loving': On the prowl with Dad
- New in paperback
- 'Sawtelle' author doggedly pursued excellence
- The story of 'Sawtelle' author is a must-read
- Author of 'Time Is a River' casts for deeper meaning
- Book roundup: Kids love to flock to their animals
- African stories go to well of empathy
- Book buzz: Paging Dr. Leary
Amazon Daily
- Graphic Novel Thursday: The Fog Mound
- YA Wednesday: Hunger Games, Locus Mag, Mundania, and More
- Arthur C. Clarke Award Winner Richard K. Morgan: Omnivoracious Guest Blogger July 7 - 11
- Barbara Hurd's Fascinating Books on Caves, Swamps, and Shorelines
- Corrupted Science by John Grant
- It Happened One Knife: Humorous Companion to Summer Movie-Going
- The Resurrection of Jack O'Connell, a True American Original
- Mirrored Heavens: David J. Williams on the Future
- Pop Culture Report #4: Bringing the Big Books
- Daniel Grandbois' Lucky Unlucky Lucky Days
Bookseller Links:
RSS FEEDS
Recent Posts
- Book Review: Messiah - The First Judgement: The Chronicles of Brothers by Wendy Alec
- Book Review: Eat This Not That! by David Zinczenko with Matt Goulding
- Book Review: Mountain Top by Robert Whitlow
- Book Review: The 12 Second Sequence by Jorge Cruise
- Book Review: The Shack by William P. Young
- Book Review: Deceptively Delicious by Jessica Seinfeld
- Book Review: How Not To Look Old by Charla Krupp
- Reading Into Presidential Hopefuls
- ‘Three Cups of Tea’ Promotes Peace, Climbs Bestseller List
- Book Review: The Yada Yada Prayer Group by Neta Jackson
SF Gate Book Reviews
- San Francisco Chronicle Best-Sellers July 6 /
- Fiction review: 'Secrets of the Sea'
- Richtel gives reading outside shuttered Cody's
- Fiction review: Read your 'Broccoli'
- Fiction review: Noah Hawley's 'The Punch'
- 'Beijing Coma' fuses China's past, present
- Baseball - both pastime and mirror
- YOUNGER READER / Women who made waves, and history
- Review: 'When You Are Engulfed in Flames'
- Fine selection of Jack London's radical prose
Author/Book Review Podcasts from NPR
Seattle Times Book Reviews
L.A. Times Book Reviews
Powell's
- The Red Prince: Between Eternity and Apocalypse
- Read It Before They Screen It: The Goon
- Book News for Thursday, July 3, 2008
- The Hazy Melodies Of The Dirtiest Old Men
- Hedonic Man — The new economics and the pursuit of happiness.
- Inside the Uprising
- Read It Before They Screen It: Gellhorn and Recoil
- Book News for Wednesday, July 2, 2008
- The Evening Redness in Your Nightmares
- Reconsiderations: “Life Studies”




Leave a Comment
trackback address